Whether it’s strength or a flaw is uncertain in my mind, but I work on the assumption that I can do most anything I put my mind to. Combined with my eternal willingness to volunteer for things, I’ve framed a house, tended bar, and I’m now in the process of organizing what could be a major fundraising event. This is particularly so when it comes to the affairs of my community, so when Deb, my neighbor and an enthusiastic community organizer approached me, I was helpless to refuse. We were at a meeting to discuss fundraising initiatives for Katrina when she cornered me. “Everyone says you’re a terrific cook,” she told me. Since Deb is a woman who wears many hats including that of caterer, I was worried and should have backed away quickly. “Um. Sure, “I said, my usual verbal abilities failing me; I hoped that at least I sounded non-committal. Deb looked pleased. “Great! I need you to bake an apple pie for the block party’s apple pie contest. The local firemen will judge it and slices will be sold for charity.” Before I could utter another um, she’d walked away to corner another unsuspecting soul.
Here’s the thing: I’m a cook, not a baker. To cook, you need to be able to taste and imagine how a combination of things will taste, while in baking, you don’t get to correct a work in progress, must be willing to pay attention to detail and follow instructions exactly, not my forte. Sure, I make cookies for the kids, cupcakes on Valentine’s Day, Strawberry Shortcake on the Fourth of July and the occasional ginger cake for the boyfriend unit, but baking is an exact and unforgiving art and not much suited to my personality. My mother was an atrocious cook who once served a dinner of canned crushed pineapple in a steamed spaghetti squash but somehow, she was a brilliant baker; to me, this is proof that the skill sets are not necessarily the same and frequently at odds. Still, how hard could it be?
A big fan of research, my first step was to call my cousin, a woman who makes her own bagels, croissants, pasta and pies. Step two was to talk to my ex, who learned to make apple pies by watching his first mother-in-law, a Missouri farm girl who had perfected the Crisco crust. I thought about the butter curst and the Crisco crust, the double crust and the lattice top, the cobbler and the Brown Betty. I looked at numerous Web sites and cookbooks. I came to two conclusions: that I had no interest in baking an all-American apple pie, and that it was time to consult my old friend Julia.
In the three decades since I started to cook, Julia Child has never let me down, and this time was no exception. She told me that I could make a tart, baked with the crust on top and then inverted. She promised that it would be delicious. Of course, I didn’t imagine that the firemen shared my interests or would care for a Francophile tart (at least of the culinary variety) but winning wasn’t my intention, I only wanted to satisfy my commitment to Deb. Once my confection was in the oven, I called Cousin Ellen, who said she’d only made that tart once, that she thought it was hard.
It wasn’t.
And I won Battery Park City’s fourth apple pie contest!
Before I begin, let me tell you that this is not a healthy snack. It’s a French recipe. It contains tons and tons of butter and lots of sugar. Deal with it. Presumably, you don’t ingest this much butter and sugar every day. Did you know that the French have the second lowest rate of heart disease in the world, behind Japan? Well, at least until recently, when McDonald’s was introduced. It’s a phenomenon known as “The French paradox,” and researches think that it’s because the French eat fresh, unprocessed food, get more exercise than we do, and eat smaller portions.
La Tarte Des Demoiselles Tatin(With some adaptations from Julia’s recipe)
First you’ll need to make a Pate Brisee Sucree (sweet short pastry)
1 Cup sifted all-purpose flour
1 Tablespoon granulated sugar
A pinch of salt
5 1/2 Tablespoons of chilled butter, cut into chunks
2 1/2 to 3 Tablespoons of very cold water.
Mix together flour, salt and sugar.
Put all ingredients except the water into your food processor and using the chopping blade, pulse until the mixture resembles fine crumbs. Add the water, a little at a time, and pulse until the mixture forms a ball. Remove the ball, smooth it out a bit, cover and place in the refrigerator while you go on to the next steps. Note that if you don’t have a food processor, you can do this with two knives, or with a pastry cutter, a device with 4-5 curved blades attached to a handle.
For a larger crust, increase measurements by 50%. For a double crust, double all measurements and divide your ball in two before chilling.
Preheat over to 375 degrees, F.
About 3-4 lbs of apples – it’s important to use Northern Spy or Jonathan apples, since they are crisp and will retain their shape. Others will turn into applesauce.
1/3 Cup of sugar
1/2 Tablespoon of cinnamon
Additional seasoning to taste – I used about 1/2 teaspoon each of nutmeg and allspice
Quarter, core and peel the apples. Cut into length-wise slices, 1/8 inch thick. If
you have a mandoline, use it. If not, use a sharp knife and be careful.
In a mixing bowl, toss apples together with sugar and spices.
Melt 6 Tablespoons of butter. You can do this in a small bowl, in your microwave.
Melt an additional 1 1/2 to 2 Tablespoons of butter in the bottom of your pie dish, which can be glass or a disposable aluminum one, and swirl the melted butter liberally along the sides. You will have a sticking problem if you skimp on the butter.
Place 1/3 of the apple mixture on the bottom of the pie dish. Since your bottom layer will become the top, you can make it pretty by arranging the slices in concentric circles, starting from the inside. Then pour a third of the melted butter over the apples. Repeat with half of the remaining apples, half of the remaining butter, and then a final layer of apples and butter. Finish the layering process by sprinkling 1/2 Cup of granulated sugar over the top.
Roll out the pastry to 1/8 inch thick. Cut it into a circle the size of the top of the baking dish and place it over the apples.
(Please note that while you can purchase marble rolling pins and pastry boards, which do prevent sticking, these thins are unnecessary. I used my grandmother’s rolling pin, put flour on my work surface and on the pin, and had no difficulty.)
Bake in the lower third of a pre-heated over, checking occasionally. If the pastry begins to brown too much, you can cover it with foil. The tart is done when you tilt the dish a bit and see that the liquid is thick brown syrup.
When done, unmold (by inverting the pie dish) immediately onto a serving dish. If the top hasn’t caramelized enough for your taste, you can sprinkle with a little sugar and run it under the broiler for a minute or two, or use a culinary blowtorch, if you have one.
It can be served hot or cold and is wonderful with crème fraiche. At least that’s what the firemen told me – I never got a bite!